If you've spent any time looking for HRT online, you've seen the ads. Midi Health. Alloy. Evernow. Winona. Four of the biggest names in direct-to-consumer menopause care, each promising a judgment-free visit, fast prescriptions, and a better experience than the OB/GYN who dismissed you. But which one actually delivers? And more importantly, which one is the right fit for you?
We spent weeks digging into pricing, insurance policies, available treatments, states served, clinician models, and what real patients say on Reddit, Facebook groups, and review sites. Here is what we found, side by side, without any affiliate spin.
The short version if you're in a hurry
All four of these companies are legitimate. All four can get you on HRT faster than most in-person providers. They differ meaningfully in price, breadth of treatments, whether they take insurance, and what the visit itself feels like. Here is the quickest summary:
- Midi Health. Takes insurance. Uses nurse practitioners trained in menopause care. Best if you want an experience that feels most like traditional medical care and you have insurance that covers it.
- Alloy. Self-pay only, flat subscription. Offers the widest range of treatments, including testosterone and vaginal estrogen, and has strong menopause credentials among its clinicians. Best if you know what you want and you want options.
- Evernow. Self-pay only. Streamlined, questionnaire-heavy experience, with clinicians who review your answers and prescribe accordingly. Best if you want efficient and no-nonsense.
- Winona. Self-pay only. Focused on bioidentical hormone therapy and compounded options. Best if you're specifically interested in compounded HRT.
Midi Health
Model: Video visits with nurse practitioners, scheduled appointments, follow-up messaging.
Price: Accepts most major insurance plans. Out-of-pocket cost for an uninsured visit is similar to a specialist copay. Medications billed separately through your pharmacy.
States: Available in all 50 states.
Treatments offered: Full range of systemic and local HRT, including estrogen patches, gels, pills, progesterone, vaginal estrogen, and non-hormonal options.
Testosterone: Available through Midi, though individual clinicians vary in how comfortable they are prescribing it.
What patients like: The visits feel like real medical care. Clinicians are trained specifically in menopause, and many are Menopause Society certified. Insurance coverage is a major draw for women who would otherwise be paying hundreds of dollars out of pocket. Follow-ups are easy.
What patients don't like: Wait times for appointments can stretch to several weeks in busy states. Some women report inconsistency between clinicians, so the experience depends a lot on who you get. Because insurance is involved, there's more paperwork than with flat-subscription services.
Best for: Women who have decent insurance, want a traditional medical experience, and are willing to wait a few weeks for an appointment in exchange for lower costs.
Alloy
Model: Asynchronous written visit (not video), reviewed by a clinician, followed by prescription and ongoing messaging. Subscription-based.
Price: Self-pay only. Monthly subscription covers the consultation and ongoing care. Medications shipped from Alloy's pharmacy partners, typically included in the subscription or at a flat rate.
States: Available in most states.
Treatments offered: Probably the widest range of the four. Estrogen patches, pills, gels, progesterone, vaginal estrogen, testosterone, and more. They prominently offer testosterone for women, which still sets them apart.
Testosterone: Yes, readily offered.
What patients like: Clinicians are menopause-focused, often with strong credentials. The breadth of treatment options is unusual. Testosterone is offered without the usual fight. The asynchronous model is fast, often getting women prescribed within 24 to 48 hours. Medication delivery is easy.
What patients don't like: No live video visits can feel impersonal for women who want conversation. It's self-pay, and while the subscription is predictable, it's not cheap. Not every state is covered.
Best for: Women who already know they want HRT, who are interested in testosterone, and who want the fewest hurdles to getting started.
Evernow
Model: Detailed online questionnaire, clinician review, prescription. Subscription with ongoing adjustments.
Price: Self-pay only. Monthly subscription includes visits and medication shipments.
States: Available in most states.
Treatments offered: Full systemic HRT, progesterone, and some non-hormonal options. More limited than Alloy in terms of testosterone access.
Testosterone: Limited or not offered depending on the state and the specific clinician.
What patients like: The intake questionnaire is thorough. Clinicians adjust doses based on symptom feedback over time. Women report feeling listened to. Shipping is reliable.
What patients don't like: Testosterone isn't always on the menu. The no-video approach isn't for everyone. Some women report wanting more flexibility in the types of HRT offered.
Best for: Women who want a streamlined, efficient experience and are comfortable with standard HRT rather than needing every option.
Winona
Model: Questionnaire-based, clinician review, compounded bioidentical hormone therapy through a partnered pharmacy.
Price: Self-pay only. Monthly subscription includes consultation, medication, and ongoing adjustments.
States: Available in most states.
Treatments offered: Primarily compounded bioidentical HRT. Less emphasis on FDA-approved commercial products.
Testosterone: Offered, usually as part of a compounded formulation.
What patients like: Easy process. Compounded options that some women feel work better for them. Strong focus on bioidentical hormones.
What patients don't like: Heavy reliance on compounded hormones is controversial. The Menopause Society and major medical bodies generally recommend FDA-approved products first when clinically equivalent, and compounded products are not subject to the same quality oversight. This doesn't mean they're unsafe, but it's something to understand going in.
Best for: Women who specifically want compounded bioidentical HRT and understand the tradeoffs.
How to choose
If you have good insurance and you want a traditional medical experience, start with Midi. If you want the most options and the fewest hurdles, especially around testosterone, Alloy is hard to beat. If you want streamlined efficiency, Evernow works. If you specifically want compounded bioidenticals, Winona is built for that.
Whichever you choose, remember that telehealth HRT is a tool, not a magic solution. The clinician matters more than the brand. Ask questions, advocate for what you need, and be willing to switch if the fit isn't right. You can also combine telehealth with a local specialist for more complex needs.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Pricing and availability change frequently. Verify current details directly with each company before enrolling.
Compare telehealth and local HRT providers in one place
Our directory includes all four of these telehealth companies plus thousands of in-person HRT specialists, so you can see every option side by side.
Find a Provider